Fact check: Maldives did not breach Kuwait Fund rules as claimed by Minister Khaleel

Mar 26, 2024, 10:33 AM
Health Minister Abdulla Khaleel.

Health Minister Abdulla Khaleel.

The Kuwait Fund cancelled plans to finance the development of 30-bed hospitals on seven islands over violations of its procurement policy in the process of awarding the projects, Health Minister Dr. Abdulla Khaleel said on Monday last week after he was summoned for questioning in Parliament.

In response to questions from Velidhoo MP Mohamed Shafeeq Abdulla and Milandhoo MP Ali Riza, Khaleel said the hospital projects planned on their islands with Kuwaiti grant aid stalled because the Kuwait Fund has stopped financing for various reasons.

After Khaleel's response, Thaa Vilufushi MP Hassan Afeef asked the minister to explain the reason for the Kuwait Fund's withdrawal of funds.

In response, Khaleel said international funding agencies have certain rules for procurement practices. The Kuwait Fund withdrew financing because the process for awarding the projects had been carried out in violation of its procurement rules, he said.

"According to my information, the Kuwait Fund has stopped it completely because the Maldives at the time wanted to carry out the awarding process in a certain way. Therefore, [the funding was withdrawn] because it was carried out in violation of the Kuwait Fund's procurement policy, we have been informed," Khaleel said last week.

Kuwait Fund issued "no objection" document to Maldives

However, Adhadhu has obtained "no objection" documents issued to the Maldives from the Kuwait Fund after the Health Ministry completed the bid awarding process and shared details with the agency. The "no objection" letters were issued after the Kuwait Fund assessed the bid awarding process.

In a letter with the reference number KF/9G11-48 sent to the Maldives on April 16, 2023, the Kuwait Fund responded to documents sent over on April 11, 2016 with recommendations from the National Tender Board after evaluations of the companies that submitted bids to develop the seven hospitals.

With its reply, the Kuwait Fund issued "no objection" documents to going ahead with the recommendations of the Maldives tender board. This was done after reviewing a tender evaluation report compiled by the Maldives on March 12, 2023.

The document included:

  • Awarding the development of a 30-bed hospital in Alif Dhaal Maamigili to Duplex Pvt Ltd - MVR 101,327,176.03
  • Awarding the development of a 30-bed hospital in Noonu Velidhoo to Buildtech Pvt Ltd - MVR 95,627,718.16
  • Awarding the development of a 30-bed hospital in Thaa Vilufushi to Duplex Pvt Ltd - MVR 109,377,431.15
  • Awarding the development of a 30-bed hospital in Haa Dhaal Hanimaadhoo to Duplex Pvt Ltd - MVR 90,512,216.05
  • Awarding the development of a 30-bed hospital in Shaviyani Milandhoo to Anand Buildtech Pvt Ltd - MVR 95,627,718.15
  • Awarding the development of a 30-bed hospital in Kaafu Thulusdhoo to Anand Buildtech Pvt Ltd - MVR 91,767,709.06
  • Awarding the development of a 30-bed hospital in Vaavu Felidhoo to Duplex Pvt Ltd - MVR 102,049,555.63

Kuwait Fund did not withdraw funds

In addition to Minister Khaleel, President Dr. Mohamed Muizzu also said in Haa Dhaal Hanimaadhoo on February 26 that the Kuwait Fund has withdrawn the funds.

However, the President gave the previous government's delays on the hospital projects as the reason for Kuwait Fund's decision.

A senior Finance Ministry official confirmed to Adhadhu that the Kuwait Fund has not withdrawn funding for developing 30-bed hospitals on seven islands.

After responding to questions from MPs and claiming that the Kuwait Fund has withdrawn the project funding, Khaleel told MPs on Monday last week that he would seek further information and update Parliament at a later date.

According to the Finance Ministry official, there were delays in the disbursement of funding from Kuwait to the Maldives due to political upheaval and frequent changes of government in the country.

The Kuwaiti government changed eight times in the past four years due to political instability in the country.

Comments

Read More

Latest News

Life imprisonment for treason under proposed amendments

The Maldivian government has proposed a bill to classify treason as a first-degree felony punishable by life imprisonment. The amendment defines treason as waging war or threatening national sovereignty and bars convicts from state office. This move fulfills a campaign pledge by President Muizzu to impose harsher penalties for betraying the nation.

New amendment criminalises "intentional acts" to harm the economy

The government is amending the Penal Code to criminalize "intentional acts" that harm the economy, with penalties of up to 10 years in prison. Critics argue the law aims to suppress opposition to major state projects like the Rasmalé deal. This move, alongside new media controls, raises significant concerns regarding freedom of expression.

Anti-religious sentiment to be criminalised

The Maldives government has introduced a bill to criminalize genocide and public incitement against religious or ethnic groups. While officially aimed at international compliance, critics fear the broad language will be used to suppress dissent and activism against the Rasmalé deal and Zionist interests.

MDP MPs urge public referendum over Rasmale' deal

MDP lawmakers are calling for a public referendum over a deal to grant 500 hectares of Rasmalé land to a foreign company on a 99-year lease. The opposition argues that such a significant transfer of territory requires direct citizen approval. They insist the public must have the final say on the project's long-term implications.

Four Bangladeshis arrested for smuggling 6kg drugs

Four Bangladeshi nationals were arrested in the Maldives for smuggling 6.75kg of synthetic cathinones via air cargo. The suspects were remanded in custody following a joint operation by police and customs. Separately, a Maldivian man was detained for ingesting 19 drug-filled capsules.

Amendment to allow home-schooling for children with disabilities

MP Anara Naeem introduced an amendment to the Education Act to allow free home-schooling for children with disabilities. The bill permits exemptions from physical school attendance based on a child's specific needs and established guidelines. It also clarifies that those unable to participate in any schooling are exempt from requirements.

Turkish firm ordered to pay MVR 25 million in unpaid taxes

The Maldives High Court ordered Turkish firm Turmaks to pay MVR 25 million in unpaid GST for materials used to build Tree Top Hospital. The court upheld MIRA's assessment, rejecting the company's claim that a verbal agreement shifted tax liability. The ruling emphasizes that the burden of proof for tax exemptions lies with the taxpayer.

Newsletter

Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox