High court case prepared to revoke president's letter to Mauritius

Jun 20, 2023, 1:06 PM
Umar at a press conference held against the government's stand in the boundary dispute. -- Photo: Mohamed Shabin/ Adhadhu

Umar at a press conference held against the government's stand in the boundary dispute. -- Photo: Mohamed Shabin/ Adhadhu

Preparations are underway to petition the high court to revoke a letter sent by president Ibrahim Mohamed Solih to the Mauritius prime minister recognizing the country's sovereignty over the Chagos archipelago.

The case was first filed at the Supreme Court on April 27 on behalf of presidential candidate and former home minister Umar Naseer along with Mohamed Musthaq and retired liutenant colonel Zubair Ahmed Manik.

But the court's registrar decided that the case could not be registered at the Supreme Court. Lawyers representing Umar asked the Supreme Court's council of judges to review the registrar's decision.

Umar Naseer told Adhadhu that the Supreme Court clarified that the high court has the jurisdiction to hear the constitutional case in the first stage. Preparations are now underway to file the case at the high court.

"Our lawyers are preparing and getting ready to file the case at the high court as soon as possible," Umar said.

The Supreme Court was petitioned to declare that the president's letter to the Mauritius prime minister was unconstitutional.

According to the case documents, the point raised to back the argument was article three of the constitution, which states that any changes to the territory of the Maldives must be approved by at least a two-thirds majority of parliament.

"There is no doubt that territorial changes include omitting a part of the territory, adding a part to the territory, and making any changes to the rights afforded to Maldivians in relation to international seas," the case stated.

The dispute

The decision by the International Tribunal on the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) to demarcate a border between the Maldives and Mauritius amounted to ITLOS agreeing that Mauritius had sovereignty over Chagos. It was this that the Maldives objected to during the first stage of the dispute.

The Maldives stand at the time was that ITLOS lacked jurisdiction to hear the case as sovereignty over Chagos was in dispute. But ITLOS rejected the Maldives' objection and proceeded with the case. The Maldives changed the stand after that.

The UN General Assembly adopted a resolution in 2019 calling for the implementation of an advisory opinion by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) that Mauritius should have sovereignty over Chagos. Along with Britain, the Maldives, America, Australia, Hungary and Israel voted against the resolution.

Mauritius petitioned various international forums to seek sovereignty over the Chagos archipelago, which was not a part of the country when it gained independence from Britain and established a state. The case filed with the ICJ was one such attempt.

The ITLOS judgment

Neither the Maldives nor Chagos has the full 200-nautical mile exclusive economic zone and there is an overlapping area of about 92,000 square kilometers. 

A maritime border was never demarcated because of the longstanding sovereignty dispute over Chagos.

In cases where countries do not agree on determining a boundary, international norms say "equidistance" must be followed. The main dispute between the countries at ITLOS concerned the baselines for determining the boundary. 

In Mauritius's proposal, the base point was a low-tide elevation called Bleinhem Reef. The Maldives objected to this, arguing that a base point could not be set at reefs visible in low tide. 

In its judgment, ITLOS supported the arguments made by the Maldives. The judgment delivered by a special chamber of ITLOS held that there were no grounds to draw the equidistant line from a low-tide reef to determine the boundary. 

The ITLOS judgment divided the 92,563 square kilometers overlapping area with 47,232 kilometers to the Maldives and 45,331 kilometers to Mauritius.

Comments

Read More

Latest News

Scholars urge government to halt Eagle Hills Rasmalé project

The Scholars’ Union of the Maldives is urging the government to halt the $12 billion Ras Malé project with Eagle Hills. The group claims the deal violates Islamic law and the constitution by potentially allowing non-Muslims to settle permanently. They warn the project could cause irreversible harm to the nation’s religious identity.

Parliament advances Real Estate Bill

The Maldives parliament advanced a bill allowing foreign property buyers to renew 99-year leases indefinitely. By issuing a new lease upon each resale, the law bypasses constitutional limits to boost the real estate market. The bill also formalizes a $12 billion deal with a developer for the Ras Malé project.

Government signs third deal for Ihavandhippolhu

The Maldives government signed a third agreement for the Ihavandhippolhu project, this time with Abu Dhabi’s SAH Group. The deal covers a commercial port and tourism infrastructure for the Maldives Economic Gateway. This follows two previous agreements with foreign firms that have yet to result in any physical work on the site.

Next year’s budget plans no hiring for new posts: Finance

The Maldives finance ministry announced that next year's budget includes no hiring for new positions to ensure economic sustainability. Officials stated that current salaries align with state revenue and that a 10% cap on overtime pay was necessary to prevent debt. No base salaries will be cut under the new pay harmonization framework.

Defamation bill aims to hide government corruption: Fittey

MP Hussain Ziyad criticized a proposed defamation bill, claiming its true purpose is to shield government corruption from public scrutiny. He warned that the bill's vague language and heavy fines, ranging up to MVR 500,000, threaten free speech. Ziyad argued the law mirrors past efforts to suppress reports on government misconduct.

Pension office dismisses COO Shiuna

The Maldives Pension Administration Office dismissed COO Mariyam Shiuna following her suspension in September. Shiuna was reportedly ousted after raising concerns about the chairperson and opposing a government plan to print money through the office. She previously led the Anti-Corruption Commission before joining the agency in 2023.

Defamation bill aims to stifle criticism of Rasmalé deal: Mauroof

MP Mauroof Zakir claims a new defamation bill aims to silence criticism of the Ras Male project and government accountability. The legislation proposes heavy fines and jail time for statements, gestures, or art deemed defamatory. Mauroof argues the bill is a tool to hide corruption and financial mismanagement from public scrutiny.

Newsletter

Get the latest news delivered straight to your inbox